Is This Bride Wrong For “Stealing” Her Step-Sister’s First Dance Song? She Asks Reddit For Advice

Rae Batchelor | November 7, 2024 7:00 pm

Weddings can be a beautiful time, but they can also be prime breeding grounds for family drama.

One woman went viral after asking if she was in the wrong for choosing the same first dance at her wedding as her step-sister did — and her reasoning had the internet talking!

Drama is often on the menu at weddings

27-dresses_c2765cca
20th Century Fox
20th Century Fox

There are a lot of heightened emotions when it comes to wedding planning -- a huge guest list of people very important to you and a lot of social etiquettes to learn and follow.

One woman took to Reddit to find out if she was breaking that etiquette with her music choices.

ADVERTISEMENT

She went to the subreddit AITA

ADVERTISEMENT
luwadlin-bosman-P_HRPYpFTNA-unsplash
Unsplash | Luwadlin
Unsplash | Luwadlin
ADVERTISEMENT

The subreddit, known as AITA, is frequented by people asking if they're in the wrong (or "the AH," a short form for a profane term for a jerk) following a conflict or argument.

ADVERTISEMENT

This woman decided to let Reddit weigh in on her wedding drama.

ADVERTISEMENT

She started off by saying it was a pretty simple story

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
father-of-the-bride_999e35a1
Touchstone Pictures
Touchstone Pictures
ADVERTISEMENT

The bride-to--to-be asked, "AITA AITA for not wanting to change my first dance song because of my step-sister's association with it?

ADVERTISEMENT

"Pretty much what the title says, so I'm going to keep it quick." The post now has 16k upvotes and 5k comments.

ADVERTISEMENT

"We've chosen our first dance song..."

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
alvin-mahmudov-NSVJAAXOYHs-unsplash
Unsplash | Alvin Mahmudov
Unsplash | Alvin Mahmudov
ADVERTISEMENT

"My step-sister is not at all happy because she and her ex-husband also had this at their wedding, and she said she has a lot of memories with this particular song," she explained.

ADVERTISEMENT

She left out a crucial detail, though.

ADVERTISEMENT

"She asked if I could change it."

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
getty-images--vGc1BpftK8-unsplash
Unsplash+
Unsplash+
ADVERTISEMENT

"I told her I get it, but this is what we want, and I don't want to change it."

ADVERTISEMENT

"She said she understood, but she's been acting different around me and I could tell she was mad/upset," the woman went on.

ADVERTISEMENT

The woman added that most people she knew agreed with her

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
runaway-bride_XZNdfz
Touchstone Pictures
Touchstone Pictures
ADVERTISEMENT

"Most people who know about this don't think I'm doing anything wrong, but I had my sister and one of my friends tell me I'm being selfish and not understanding here," she went on.

ADVERTISEMENT

That's when things got interesting.

ADVERTISEMENT

Some things were still left unsaid

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
jeremy-wong-weddings-464ps_nOflw-unsplash
Unsplash | Jeremy Wong Weddings
Unsplash | Jeremy Wong Weddings
ADVERTISEMENT

"Some people are asking to edit in my comments so here they are," she wrote in an edit to her original post.

ADVERTISEMENT

"A few months after they got married, he was in a wreck, he thankfully survived but has a very severe TBI (among other things)."

ADVERTISEMENT

She went on with more details

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
8fight1
20th Century Fox
20th Century Fox
ADVERTISEMENT

"He lives in a specialized nursing home," she explained. "They did get divorced, but my sister still goes on about how she loves him and visits him occasionally."

ADVERTISEMENT

Then she added more context about her sister's relationship with the song.

ADVERTISEMENT

The song holds a very special meaning for her sister and her ex

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
skye-studios-L6zXAJD01Ak-unsplash
Unsplash | Skye Studio
Unsplash | Skye Studio
ADVERTISEMENT

The woman explained, "He doesn't remember who she is most of the time, but my sister said she apparently sang this song to him and he 'looks like he remembers her' (her words)."

ADVERTISEMENT

She also revealed the song itself.

ADVERTISEMENT

The song: "Come What May" from Moulin Rouge!

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
moulin-rouge_ry80Vj
20th Century Fox
20th Century Fox
ADVERTISEMENT

The song the bride-to-be selected was "Come What May" from the movie Moulin Rouge! It details a promise between lovers to always love each other until the end of time, "come what may."

ADVERTISEMENT

She wrote, "My sister sees it as 'their' song, she and her ex first met at the movies when they both went to watch it."

ADVERTISEMENT

The story continues...

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
27-dresses_DvwLSS
20th Century Fox
20th Century Fox
ADVERTISEMENT

"Then apparently the restaurant they went to for their first date was also playing it, so they took it as a sign. And as I said, they also played it at their wedding," she explained.

ADVERTISEMENT

But that wasn't all.

ADVERTISEMENT

"She also sings it to him sometimes now."

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
elvis-bekmanis-WJc87MVcDaA-unsplash
Unsplash | Elvis Bekmanis
Unsplash | Elvis Bekmanis
ADVERTISEMENT

"I think it's a really nice song and I'd like to play it too, I don't want to have to change it," her post finished.

ADVERTISEMENT

The post immediately caught a lot of people's attention.

ADVERTISEMENT

Reactions to her story were mixed

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
vadim-paripa-PuXtB1B4zL8-unsplash
Unsplash | Vadim Paripa
Unsplash | Vadim Paripa
ADVERTISEMENT

Before she had edited her post to add context to the situation, most people seemed to agree that she was under no obligation to change her song choice for her step-sister.

ADVERTISEMENT

Once the full story came to light, the comments changed their tone.

ADVERTISEMENT

One comment asked her to put herself in her step-sister's shoes.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
bride-wars_7da4b50c
20th Century Fox
20th Century Fox
ADVERTISEMENT

"Imagine that your husband died. Only he didn't actually die, because he's still alive. He just doesn't remember you," they wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

"Whenever you come into the room it's like your heart is getting ripped out because the person you love most in the world sees you as a stranger, someone who doesn't matter to him."

ADVERTISEMENT

The comment, which received over 37k upvotes, continued

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
eugenivy_now-1Bs2sZ9fD2Q-unsplash
Unsplash | Євгенія Височина
Unsplash | Євгенія Височина
ADVERTISEMENT

"Your first song is the only thing that makes him even somewhat remember you, if only for a moment because you know the moment you leave the room he's forgetting you all over again," they went on.

ADVERTISEMENT

The comments didn't stop there.

ADVERTISEMENT

People were quickly turning against the future bride's choice

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
jayson-hinrichsen-Fx-biIYsYJA-unsplash
Unsplash | Jayson Henrichsen
Unsplash | Jayson Henrichsen
ADVERTISEMENT

"No," the comment continued.

ADVERTISEMENT

"The guy is still alive, and each time you see him, it's like you're losing him all over again, making it difficult to make a new life."

ADVERTISEMENT

"Then you find out your stepsister wants to play the ONE SONG that means the most to you."

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
bridesmaids_7a1a8776
Universal Studios
Universal Studios
ADVERTISEMENT

"(And, you think, to your brain-dead husband)," the commenter wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

"You have to watch someone else be happy and have the best day while you think about everything you lost and can never get back."

ADVERTISEMENT

Commenters thought the original poster's attitude was strange

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
victoria-priessnitz-JFAPl7brL6U-unsplash
Unsplash | Victoria Priessnitz
Unsplash | Victoria Priessnitz
ADVERTISEMENT

"[I] Was prepared to say [you weren't in the wrong] based on the main post, but finding out that there is no special connection to the song and that you liked it at your sister's wedding now reeks of some kind of weird dynamic" one commenter wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

But some still thought the bride had every right to the song.

ADVERTISEMENT

She's "choosing to inflict pain..."

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
bride-wars_90abf373
20th Century Fox
20th Century Fox
ADVERTISEMENT

"Yeah, it's 'her wedding, her choice'," one commenter wrote, adding that "she is CHOOSING to inflict pain on her sister who has suffered an unimaginable tragedy."

ADVERTISEMENT

But not everyone felt she was in the wrong.

ADVERTISEMENT

Some people felt that the situation had a little nuance

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
bridesmaids_54f3f9
Universal Studios
Universal Studios
ADVERTISEMENT

"In a normal situation, I would say, 'it's a common song, no one owns it, she should get over herself,'" one commenter wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

"But after reading about your sister's situation, I completely understand her response. When we lose someone, we cling to those small reminders."

ADVERTISEMENT

Some wondered how she could even consider using the song

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
katelyn-macmillan-MtwNya-3mac-unsplash
Unsplash | Katelyn MacMillan
Unsplash | Katelyn MacMillan
ADVERTISEMENT

"She has suffered such a great loss, and the song is a comfort to her."

ADVERTISEMENT

"For me, that would mar the song for my own wedding. But that's just me," one user wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

The bride-to-be didn't have an emotional connection to the song

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
leonardo-miranda-riHGdvluDk8-unsplash
Unsplash | Leonardo Miranda
Unsplash | Leonardo Miranda
ADVERTISEMENT

"If the song had a huge reason for being your first choice, I'd say stick with it. But right now, it reads like you chose it on a whim because you like it," one commenter wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

"You're willing to hurt your step-sister over a "nice song." I'm sorry, but that doesn't make you a nice person."

ADVERTISEMENT

Using the song showed poor judgement

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
victoria-priessnitz-pU_A9uhqcBU-unsplash
Unsplash | Victoria Priessnitz
Unsplash | Victoria Priessnitz
ADVERTISEMENT

"No, your step-sister's emotions aren't your responsibility. No, your step-sister doesn't own the song," one user replied. "No, she isn't entitled to tell you what to do on your wedding day."

ADVERTISEMENT

"But with all that in mind, if you actually care about her feelings, then this would make [you the one in the wrong]."

ADVERTISEMENT

Users pointed out that context really mattered

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
jonathan-borba-g3oEF_BNXwE-unsplash
Unsplash | Jonathan Borba
Unsplash | Jonathan Borba
ADVERTISEMENT

"I understand that normally it wouldn't matter, but given the context, unless it has a deep meaning for you & SO, it's kind of creepy to take a song that you KNOW she keeps so close to her heart and use it for your own wedding," one commenter wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

Still, the internet was definitely divided.

ADVERTISEMENT

Some weren't "sure" they could make a call on the sitaution

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ye-qing-DmzQhBMOGjg-unsplash
Unsplash | ye qing
Unsplash | ye qing
ADVERTISEMENT

"Because nobody owns the song," one person wrote, "but I'll admit I feel a little strange/uncomfortable about your insistence on using it in spite of the lack of emotional connection."

ADVERTISEMENT

"And in the context of her emotional connection."

ADVERTISEMENT

One commenter wrote that it's "up to you"

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
osarugue-igbinoba-Rnpl4bDDBog-unsplash
Unsplash | Osarugue Igbinoba
Unsplash | Osarugue Igbinoba
ADVERTISEMENT

"It's up to you to know if 'I like it' is equally important to you as 'It's a very emotional memory of something I've lost in a horrible way and the last remaining connection to my nearly dead ex-husband,'" the commenter wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

"Up to you..."

ADVERTISEMENT

"If I were your sister, I wouldn't even go to the wedding."

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
kyle-broad-P9rQn2qcEV0-unsplash
Kyle Broad/Unsplash
Kyle Broad/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

"And, honestly, I'd go low contact with you! Her ex-husband literally can't remember her, and she goes there and sings this same song to him," they wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

"You know how much this song means to her and are still being selfish!"

ADVERTISEMENT

The song meant a lot to her sister

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
afif-ramdhasuma-mv38TB_Ljj8-unsplash
Unsplash | Afif Ramdhasuma
Unsplash | Afif Ramdhasuma
ADVERTISEMENT

"Her husband suffered a traumatic injury, and that song is possibly the only thing that reminds him of his love for your sister. Their relationship is wrapped around that song and its significance to them," they wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ultimately, it came down to one repeated point.

ADVERTISEMENT

"Pick a different song."

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
blocks-T3mKJXfdims-unsplash
Unsplash | blocks
Unsplash | blocks
ADVERTISEMENT

"You can like the song, but leave it alone at your wedding."

ADVERTISEMENT

"Let something from her marriage, which was tragically cut short, remain just about the good times she had with her husband. Do not turn it into the thing that reminds her of how selfish you are," one user wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

What do you think?

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
jonathan-borba-yigM_oC6GgY-unsplash
Unsplash | Jonathan Borba
Unsplash | Jonathan Borba
ADVERTISEMENT

Do you agree with the commenters that the song is simply too emotionally weighted for the woman's step-sister and that she should leave it alone?

ADVERTISEMENT

Or do you think that she has a right to use whatever song she wants at her wedding?