These Two Brothers Solved The Mystery Of Oak Island

Burtland Dixon | December 12, 2023 7:38 pm

Are you ready for a treasure hunt like no other? The mystery of Oak Island has been tantalizing treasure hunters for centuries and it's not for the faint of heart. But in 1965, two brothers, Rick and Marty Lagina, set out to uncover the secrets that Oak Island holds.

These brothers are no strangers to the island, they've been obsessed with it for decades and they might just be the ones to finally crack the code and uncover the treasure. If you're ready for an adventure of a lifetime, read on onwards on to learn about the Lagina brothers and their quest to solve the mystery of Oak Island.

Childhood Treasure Hunting

top-view-of-four-hands-on-map-of-pirates-treasure-2022-04-22-04-46-28-utc
Envato Elements / boomeart
Envato Elements / boomeart

At 10 years old, Rick embarked on his first treasure hunt, unaware of Oak Island. Moving a granite rock revealed nothing of value, but Rick's fascination with the pursuit outweighed the disappointment.

With the help of eight friends and his brother Marty, they undertook the challenge, setting the stage for more difficult quests. Rick's passion for the chase surpassed the allure of potential discoveries, setting him on a lifelong journey.

ADVERTISEMENT

Fun Game Became A Passion

ADVERTISEMENT
retro-magnifier-with-old-map-2021-08-26-15-55-30-utc
Envato Elements / byrdyak
Envato Elements / byrdyak
ADVERTISEMENT

One fateful day, Rick Lagina's mundane routine took an extraordinary turn as he stumbled upon a captivating article in Reader's Digest, detailing the enigmatic Oak Island in Nova Scotia, Canada.

ADVERTISEMENT

Intrigued by the legendary tale of a cursed island hiding a fabled treasure, Rick's curiosity morphed into an all-consuming obsession. Throughout his life, he had yearned to unearth hidden riches, and now the prospect of pursuing his long-held dream consumed his every thought.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Practical Brother

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-1411412963
Photo by Bill Tompkins/Getty Images
Photo by Bill Tompkins/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Marty Lagina is often seen as the more pragmatic and level-headed of the Lagina brothers, while Rick Lagina has always been the dreamer, captivated by the tales of Oak Island from a young age. It was Rick who initially sparked the idea of pursuing the treasure hunt and convinced Marty to join him in investing in the tour group.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite his skepticism about the true purpose of the quest, Marty recognizes his brother's unwavering determination and understands that Rick won't rest until he unravels the island's mystery, even if it means risking everything.

ADVERTISEMENT

A Stone Tablet With A Secret Code Was Found

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
stone-plate-with-inscriptions-in-ancient-city-hier-2021-08-26-15-27-08-utc
Envato Elements / Stramyk
Envato Elements / Stramyk
ADVERTISEMENT

It was 1804 when the Onslow Company came into being. The company was formed to search the island after a young boy found a circular depression on the ground. The original team dug into the depression, cutting through layers of wood and charcoal on the way.

ADVERTISEMENT

Their efforts were rewarded when they discovered a stone tablet with an odd inscription. For 62 years, no one was able to decipher what the tablet said. Finally, in 1866, a language professor from Halifax University broke the code, revealing an ominous message.

ADVERTISEMENT

Numerous Oak Island Theories

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-1229056014
DigitalGlobe/ScapeWare3d / Contributor via Getty Images
DigitalGlobe/ScapeWare3d / Contributor via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

There are several theories as to how the treasure ended up at Oak Island. We'll cover two of them here. The first one claims the treasure is Marie Antionette's. In this story she had her maid flee Paris during the French Revolution, hiding half her belongings in London and the other half in Nova Scotia.

ADVERTISEMENT

The second theory says the treasure belonged to Francis Bacon. Bacon claimed to be the original author of Shakespeare's plays. A pit was built at Oak Island to hide Bacon's original transcripts. In the process, numerous other treasures were buried there. Which theory do you believe?

ADVERTISEMENT

The Hunt For Treasure Starts

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
metal-detector-coil-in-action-above-the-ground-2021-09-03-02-33-53-utc
Envato Elements / Fabrika Photo
Envato Elements / Fabrika Photo
ADVERTISEMENT

In 1847, the Truro Company began digging at Oak Island. After drilling through the ground, they hit paydirt. They pierced through two chests full of coins and managed to recover three gold links that appeared to be from a chain.

ADVERTISEMENT

Not surprisingly, the gold went missing. After years of searching for more treasure, the Truro Company gave up, unable to stop the flooding created by the Onslow Company. They may have given up, but new explorers came in droves, some willing to lose their lives to uncover incredible riches never seen before.

ADVERTISEMENT

Years Pass, Explorers Die, And Intrigue Remains

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
ADVERTISEMENT

As the years passed, more and more explorers took to Oak Island to solve the puzzle. The Triton Alliance was formed in the 1970s to provide money and technology for the search. Still, no matter how far the team dug, all they found were small clues like logs with Roman carvings or leather shoes.

ADVERTISEMENT

For the next 25 years, no one explored the island. Legal rights belonged to the Triton Alliance, who had abandoned their dig and got caught in their own squabbles with each other. In 2005, the property went up for sale, and Robert and Marty Lagina jumped on the chanced to get in on the hunt!

ADVERTISEMENT

The Lagina Brother Purchase Their Way Back Into The Picture

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: History Channel
Photo Credit: History Channel
ADVERTISEMENT

When 2005 rolled around, a portion of Oak Island went up for sale. The cost was around seven million dollars, money the Lagina brothers happened to have thanks to their lucrative drilling business. The Oak Island Tourism Society urged the Canadian government to step in and buy the land, but they never did.

ADVERTISEMENT

To make sure they could outbid anyone, they bought a 50 percent stake in Oak Island Tours Incorporated. With the island secure, they had their chance to unearth the truth buried at Oak Island. It didn't take long for them to start making some big discoveries.

ADVERTISEMENT

They Got Their Own Television Series

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
tv-show-36061-50135.jpg
Photo Credit: RICARDO ARDUENGO/AFP/Getty Images
Photo Credit: RICARDO ARDUENGO/AFP/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

The Lagina brothers' search was put in the spotlight in 2014 when the History Channel made them the subjects of a documentary television show. The Curse of Oak Island was a massive hit for the network and is still running after more than five seasons on the air.

ADVERTISEMENT

More importantly, the show added credibility to the treasure hunt and provided Rick and Marty extra funding for their adventure.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Brothers Had New Technology On Their Side

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: RICARDO ARDUENGO/AFP/Getty Images
Photo Credit: RICARDO ARDUENGO/AFP/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Finally able to take their crack at Oak Island, the Lagina brothers had one major advantage; 21st-century technology. By taking advantage of tools that weren't available 50 years before, they could scour the whole island in hopes of finding clues.

ADVERTISEMENT

Using everything at their disposal, the brothers knew they could better explore the flooded money pit. They could also explore the human-made hole dug next to the money pit, called the "Borehole 10-X," which contained a wealth of secrets that previous explorers never knew about. Coming up, the television breakthrough that took their search to the next level.

ADVERTISEMENT

Workers With Experience Wanted

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: Tom Lee/Construction Photography/Avalon/Getty Images
Photo Credit: Tom Lee/Construction Photography/Avalon/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

As soon as the brothers got their wish to dig at Oak Island, they knew they needed help. There was no way the two of them could safely find the treasure themselves. Luckily, Marty had several connections with very experienced drillers and diggers with the machinery and skills they needed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Marty founded Terra Energy in 1982. It became Michigan's largest operator of gas wells within years. In 1995, he sold the company to open Heritage Winds Energy to help provide renewable energy. Ten years later, he called up his connections with a one-of-a-kind proposal.

ADVERTISEMENT

The First Discovery Is A Doozy

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: DeAgostini/Getty Images
Photo Credit: DeAgostini/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Everyone held their breath at the end of the first season of The Curse of Oak Island as the Lagina's made their first discovery. Using sonar technology, they found a swamp that was shallow enough to explore. Buried in the mud, they found several human-made objects, the most surprising of which was an antique Spanish coin.

ADVERTISEMENT

After their first discovery, numerous people came out of the woodwork to suggest theories. One person believed the treasure was from King Solomon's Temple. Another claimed to know a secret way to get the treasure, which belonged to Francis Bacon.

ADVERTISEMENT

Portuguese Carvings Keep The Mystery Strange

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: DeAgostini/Getty Images
Photo Credit: DeAgostini/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Three seasons into the show the Lagina's made their next significant discovery. They brought in new experts to help interpret strange sonar readings and figure out how to drain Borehole 10-X. The new blood paid off, and the results of their findings made the island even more mysterious.

ADVERTISEMENT

Among the treasures they unearthed were stones with Portuguese carvings, a Roman Sword, and several other unrelated items. The findings served as proof that different cultures had visited Oak Island over the centuries. Still, they weren't any closer to finding the big treasure.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rick Will Never Lose Faith In His Mission

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
rick-lagina-58820-21885.jpg
Photo Credit: History Channel
Photo Credit: History Channel
ADVERTISEMENT

According to Rick Lagina, "life’s a treasure hunt. We’re all on one, in our own different way, and we happen to be on a real one right now." Rick's goal is apparent by now; he needs to find the treasure buried at Oak Island. It might sound crazy, but it gives him purpose and a reason to smile when he wakes up every morning.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rick also believes, despite more confusion being added than clarity, that "Every day it feels like we’re turning a page of a really good book. I still believe.” We hope Rick never stops believing. He deserves a happy ending after dreaming about the Island for so long.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Key To The Lagina's Success Is Their Ability To Listen

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: History Channel
Photo Credit: History Channel
ADVERTISEMENT

The Lagina's have made more progress in solving the mystery of Oak Island than any explorers before them. Charles Barkhouse, a historian on the island, said part of their success could be attributed to an asset others didn't have. Barkhouse said, "they [also have] something that other searchers didn’t have: a willingness to listen.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Barkhouse believes that previous explorers wanted full control over their expeditions, which made it impossible to make real progress. The Lagina's bring in various experts and listen to every possible solution before picking the one they believe will work best.

ADVERTISEMENT

A Dangerous Obsession

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
ADVERTISEMENT

The curse of the island says that seven people have to die before the treasure is revealed. So far, six people have lost their lives searching for the treasure. Will Rick be the seventh? Blackhouse says, "Putting one’s life at risk to find something that may or may not be buried is extreme.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Another explorer, Daniel Blankenship, came to the island from Florida 50 years ago and hasn't left since. He, like the Lagina's brothers, has put his life on hold while he waits for the secrets of the island to be revealed. The treasure could be anything, and, "that's what excites people," says Barkhouse.